Only a few years before The Pilgrim's Progress, Bunyan had written one
of the most remarkable and powerful accounts of prolonged psychological
anguish ever to have been published in English. This was his spiritual
autobiography, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners (1666), in which
he recounts in vivid and harrowing detail his own experience of religious
conversion and the psychological ordeal he had to go through before
entering upon what would be his vocation as a preacher and writer. Grace
Abounding has come to be regarded as a paradigmatic case history in
the psychology of religious belief. It has been suggested that Bunyan
was suffering from a variety of mental problems, including serious depression,
and many attempts have been made to identify in medical or psychiatric
terms what the causes of this may have been. Whether or not the evidence
allows us to make specific diagnoses, it is certainly hard for a modern
reader not to interpret Bunyan's ordeal as, in some sense, a psychological
one. Bunyan emerged from his ordeal, however, and was able to transmute
his own painful experiences into a richly imagined allegorical narrative.
In its inward-turning, isolated and agonized preoccupation with his
own experiences, Grace Abounding contrasts with the confident expansiveness
of The Pilgrim's Progress and its range of characters. But the most
important of the struggles and trials of the pilgrims continue to be
inward and psychological ones. Bunyan's representation of how his pilgrims
deal with these psychological problems is a large part of the continuing
fascination and attractiveness of his work for modern readers.